So far so so good definitely seeing changes in my cheekbones areas that have hyper pigmentation and my chin area from hormonal acne that I had that caused dark marks the toner really feels like you applied some watered down product on your face so I don’t really use it but the soap vitamin c serum and moisturizer I use every day can see the difference in my skin the toner is the only reason I’m giving it 4 stars instead of 5 stars.